Editor’s note: Joyce M. Short is the author of a just released book, “Carnal Abuse by Deceit.” The book chronicles her life with a predator, the subsequent aftermath and her road to recovery. It also provides advice for victims and their supporters, and discusses the issues surrounding criminalization of rape-by-fraud.
By Joyce M. Short
“No Contact” Is the First Step, But Not the Last!
The concept of NO CONTACT enables us to distance ourselves from harm, and regain emotional balance. But it’s not all we need to do. We need to come to grips with the real injury that we’ve endured in order to cope with our losses. Partially in an effort to cope with mine, I wrote my book, Carnal Abuse by Deceit How a Predator’s Lies Became Rape.
Most of us think of rape as an act of physical assault. But the assault, itself, is not the only harm, and is not necessarily present in all forms of rape. We can be raped by lies, fraud and deceit. We can be raped by dates who overcome our consent with drugs or alcohol. We can be raped by not being the age of consent when sexual intercourse takes place. We can be coerced into sexual intercourse by concern over possible harm to another if we don’t cooperate. What all these forms of rape have in common is that there is no direct force applied, but our sexual sanctity was breached without “knowing consent.”
The stories I’ve read of most LoveFraud participants expose their experience with either emotional rape or rape by fraud. We were defrauded of our highest emotion, which is love, (emotional rape) and some of us were fooled by fraudulent identity information of the predator who entered our lives, (rape by fraud). As a result, many of us were locked into a relationship known as a Betrayal Bond, which made walking away very difficult. On-lookers who were not faced with the same neurologically induced connection to the predator may have been bewildered by our interest in remaining in the relationship. And because these predators were such believable “con artists,” we may not have received support from people close to us who were fooled as well. My own mother was taken in by the man who defiled me.
I’ve written Carnal Abuse by Deceit — How a Predator’s Lies Became Rape, (CAD) in order to accomplish a few things I feel are important. The first is to mainstream the concept of the crime itself, and enable society to understand that the behavior is, in fact, a crime. Another is to establish that there really are people who cannot be, and should not be, trusted in the world. They are morally disordered and no amount of love or caring will fix them. The third is to provide a path that I sincerely hope will bring relief to others who struggle to recover from the devastation that occurred in their lives, and free themselves from ongoing sorrow.
Thank you so much Joyce for bringing attention to this issue. It simply is not right that exploiters get away with their deception.
idt this will ever get anywhere legally as EVERYONE thinks u shud just leave wen the guys “an idiot”. they do not GET it. they will not.
to even be trapped in this took alot of manipulation on the spaths part. to disentangle oneself is maddeningly difficult. its why women get killed b4 leaving the abuser. its why they endanger their own precious children. it’s why u “cant talk any sense into them”. it’s why they cant see “the red flags flying high”. they are lost in the labyrinth of lies and deceit and love bombing and watever other sick, twisted tricks the sick, twisted man used/is using to keep his victim. I Have Been There. the selfhate is incredible. and the blame is squarely on me in my familys opinion. “u shud have ran if he was half as bad as the (few cautious) things u have shared (out of desperation–my fear of their increased revulsion keeps me from telling most the ordeal) were true”. therefore i just made a mistake and cud have turned around.
so untrue.
but until ur caught in this kind of abuse, u wont get it. a normal abusive partner will allow u to get out. u will think everyone can therefore. u will be wrong.
Aint…you are so, so, so exactly right.
aint it a bitch to be rite SIGH
Joyce,
It is good to hear you call this what it really is. Emotional rape. I was told I was the be all and end all, the ‘first one I’ve ever wanted to marry’, blah dee blah.
If I had known the truth, I never would have become involved. the truth is rape is not a sexual act, it an act of power and violation. So, even if the victim has never even slept with the predator/liar, it is rape. They violate our trust, first, and then, if they are so inclined our bodies.
No matter how you look at it, it is rape from the first word.
Slim
lol i was his dream woman too. he pressed me to marry so badly. i held him off from july to jan. the worse thing is he wanted children very very badly too. that is the worst mistake i ever made, worse than being with him, having his children. now i fret about their genetic makeup. i rly worry as his parents are both messed up too i now realize. his mom is prob a spath too. his dad im not sure of.
SIGH
Yes, they lied to us to get into the relationship; they lied about who they were and what they really wanted to do to us. We need to ask ourselves “what was this person’s intention”. Did he want a relationship with me or to have power and control over me? He told me he loved me and wanted to marry me, as he was screwing other women in other states. He relied on lots of texting so that he could manage his lies and avoid any real depth conversation with these other women. He also relied on the distance to make sure his lies of where he was living/who he was with every night (me) were not found out by the “new shiny toy”. Do I feel bad for the other women, yes I do. Of course he lied to them about who he was. He deceived them into thinking he was not in a relationship, that he was available. That he could be in a long distance romance with them. They too were told all the same lies I was told. All for him to feed his ego, he never had any intention of every really loving me or them. It was all for him and his power trip over many women. And yes my ego has been crushed as I go over “why I was not enough for this man”? Why after all the hoops I have jumped through all the sacrifices and all the bad behavior I have tolerated and still this person did not love me and give me the relationship that I thought we were going to have. I know I have been “emotionally raped” as I allowed this man into my life and he destroyed me on a personal level. Having to admit to myself that this man never loved me is the hardest part. And now I need to rebuild my life as well as all the women who he has “raped” over the years, as they too will find out who he really is. And they will as he never keeps them longer than 3 months because by then he cannot keep the lies going. He gets tired of them and his “feeding frenzy for his ego” has been filled. His need for power and control has been satiated and he is good for a while. Then he starts again with a new toy.
Sick@heart-
It sounds like you were badly victimized by an intensely disordered man.
One of my intentions in writing “Carnal Abuse by Deceit” was to begin the conversation that can criminalize the behavior. Many states (mentioned in my book,) have penal code addressing various aspects of rape by fraud. You’ll see that the basis for the crime differs from state to state.
Changing the law, or having the existing laws implemented or standardized from state to state will take considerable information, which I’m attempting to compile. Anyone on this blog, (and that is likely to be many of you,) who feels they were the victim of emotional rape, or rape by fraud, can send me a brief note (to jm_short@ymail.com), indicating the state and city where you live. When we have a group of folks who are all on the same page from the same states, we can approach the legislators in your state with a proposal on rape by fraud penal law.
Additionally, on my blog, http://www.CADalert.blogspot.com, you can list the name and data of the person who victimized you. You can do so anonymously. The intent is simple…. it’s to stop CADs in their tracks by putting their factual information “out there” so they can no longer fool others with misinformation and lies.
Wishing you the best in your efforts to recover from your ordeal!
Joyce
Joyce, I’m having trouble accessing the comments on your blog. I think it has something to do with the Disqus software. I’ve tried two different browsers and … nothing. I’m on my work computer and I’m not in a position to upgrade those browsers. I don’t know if there’s anything you can do but I wanted to let you know. I have a story to tell *and* a CAD to report.
BTW, I have been using the term “emotional rape” for years to describe what he did to me.
Hi BagLady,
Thanks for letting me know about the difficulty you’ve had on the web page. I’ll look into the technology and try to make the necessary changes.
If you write to me directly at jm_short@ymail.com, I’ll post your CAD information and your story on your behalf.
Also, please let me know what city and state you live in so I can put you together with other folks in your state to begin to lobby for legislative change on this issue.
All the best!
Joyce
Hi,
Yes it has been a terrible awful nightmare that I just cannot move away from. I have been violated by this man. He took my “rights” away from me when he lied to me about other women. My right to ensure protection was always used. He was having unprotected sex with these women and then of course we were not using protection. My right to be in a safe realtionship, my right to make choices ( if I had known) my right to protect myself and my heart. He was reckless with my health and has put me in a position of having to ensure I have not been infected with anything. Did he violate these other women….YES…He is a 52 year old man who I am sure would tell these women he has not had sex for sooooo long and would also tell them he has had a vasectomy, therefore no protection was used. I am sick….just sick and yes I am doing no contact…but 5 years of loving this man and then to find all this out and now…..silence. I am trying my best to take 1 day at a time but the truth is I ache…my body is aching…my heart is aching….I feel so violated and so hurt that this man did this to me and has moved on without any remorse….nothing. Is this a good thing? probably but right now all I can do is just breath.
Sick@heart, I know how you feel. I was a year or two into the relationship with my abuser when he started pressuring to stop using condoms since we were “exclusive”. My gut advised caution and I waited close to another year before I was convinced (falsely) that he was not and would not have sex with anyone else. I can sill feel what a big step it was for me to agree that we didn’t need to use them anymore. Within about a year I got herpes…and when I told him, he attacked me so cruelly, telling me I made his skin crawl, and accusing me of ruining his life and wondering what other diseases I had given him…of course I was so manipulated I stayed with him for another three years before he discarded me, and he never took responsibility for the herpes and wouldn’t discuss it with me. It was certain I got it from him…I had been celibate for two years since my divorce and hadn’t had sex with anyone else. I know how you feel…I found out later this man was “dating” multiple women the entire time he was with me, several that I knew, and was deep into another relationship when we bought our dream home together in another state…he discarded me less than three months after escrow closed and left me and my financial life in shambles…2 1/2 years later I am still cleaning up the mess. Meanwhile, in less than 8 months, he married another women with his entire family around him (the family I had been a part of for 7 years) and has moved on unscathed and unimpacted. Now I know the marriage is a sham and he has not changed and will be abusing her too, and feel pretty certain he married her so quickly to “save face” and make a public show that the end of our relationship was my doing and not his, since he is so desirable, and it’s HARD. But I know I will be ok…and you will too. There are some days when all I can do is breathe too…and that’s ok…be thankful for the silence – if he returned to your life, he would only abuse you again.
hi moon,
unfortunately I have herpes as well, but my BPD wife did not give them to me, the girl before her did, however I met my wife on a herpes dating site, it was heaven until we moved in together, since its been nothing but up and down roller coaster rides full of lies, possible cheating, verbal abuse, I only hope that if she gets with someone else she at least tells him what she has before sleeping with him, but there is no telling with her anymore what she is capable of.
sry to hear it happened to you with someone you trusted, I couldn’t imagine how id have fealt if my wife gave me something.
They have herpes dating sites? Wow…who knew!
I remember so clearly when I got the call and told him about the herpes…we were on our way out of town on a weekend trip and he was driving my car…I was stunned but just felt we could handle it together. Eeep! If I had a dollar for every time I’ve wished I would have had him stop the car, hauled him out and drove away with him laying on the shoulder, I’d be a millionaire.
I’m sure he hasn’t told his new wife (or any other of the women) he has it…because of course, in his world, he doesn’t.
Sick@Heart,
I am so very sorry for the pain and agony you are feeling. You have come to the right place. I found LoveFraud a little over a year ago and my life has never been the same. The feelings you have are very valid. Don’t ever be ashamed of having them. Although we cannot go back and undo what has been done to us, we can take positive steps to move forward. I remember the nights crying out loud so long that my chest would hurt. I thought I had no more tears left, when more would flow. I thought I would never be normal again. The agony and heartache was more than I could bare. I can tell you that it does get much better. I never dreamed I would be in the state of mind that I now enjoy. I have come so far and you will too. When I feel myself slipping, I hop onto LoveFraud and read until I feel better. It always brings me back to reality. You go ahead and just breath for now. That’s perfectly fine. As I’m sure you’ve read, no contact is absolutely essential to your healing. When I decided to go no contact, I spent two days crying, deleting all of his information and pictures from my computer and packing up anything that had anything to do with him (or throwing them away). It was one of the hardest things I’ve ever had to do. I also removed all of the people from my life who were his enablers. I removed their contact information, blocked them from calling me, emailing me and contacting me on Facebook. It was hard, but looking back, it was the smartest thing I had done in a long time. Just hang in there and keep putting one foot in front of the other. One thing that has helped me is making sure I get out and get some sunshine and exercise, even if it’s just a walk around the block. For an entire year I put blankets over the blinds on the windows and did nothing but eat and watch television. This did not serve me well. The first thing I do every day now is open all of the blinds. You’ve made it this far and you can make it over the hump. We believe in you!
It was so hard to get across WHY I felt like I’d been raped with my therapist. He touched me with his foul body while continually lying about his sexual history, past and present. All the while he was demanding complete monogamy and loyalty. I cheerfully gave it and thought I was getting it in return. Ms. Loyal sat at home and never looked at another man – even when I should have. Then I found out he had taken a stripper home from a bar after he intentionally started an argument so that I would leave. When I started digging I found many one night stands with women of questionable reputation, or worse. It always happened after he intentionally started an argument. He drove me away so that he could cheat, then he’d call days later and reel me back in.
I would have never allowed him near me, let alone share bodily fluids with him, had I known what a degraded being he truly was. I was left feeling filthy, contaminated, and utterly violated and nothing could make that go away for a long time.
Onmyown-
I think one of the toughest parts of dealing with our issues is that folks who should know how we feel often don’t.
Obviously, you thought you were sharing an intimate, monogamous relationship with this man. And the discovery that you were not, was a betrayal. While you provided HIM with intimacy, and your highest emotion, love, he engaged in defilement, misuse of your body and your trust. He, indeed, emotionally raped you.
The sense of filth and contamination is similar in all rape victims. The difference is that we were not violently assaulted, (although some of us were, as well.) But that by no means changes the sense of violation we feel.
You will need to learn to cope with those feelings, and it will become easier over time. If your present therapist does not comprehend this, you might look for one who has experience with Post Traumatic Rape Syndrome and has worked with patients who were victimized by sociopaths. There are tools they can use to help you minimize your visceral response to what happened to you. I’ve mentioned some of those techniques in my book as well as other insights about healing.
An important concept to focus on is the fact that rape was an action that was done to you, but it is not who you are.
Wishing you a speedy journey to recovery!
Joyce
I’m blessed to have a great therapist who never had a lot of experience with personality disorders, but recognized that I had probably been sucked in by a sociopath. What she wanted was for me to verbalize why I felt raped and I couldn’t do it for a while. I suffered so badly from cognitive dissonance and there was PTSD, including repressed memories that were slowly making their way back into my conscious thoughts. He was also still contacting me at that time, trying desperately to keep me on the hook and insisting he had done nothing wrong. It wasn’t until I cut him loose for good that I could start putting the pieces together.
It’s been several years and I’ve dealt with all of this effectively in therapy. Sometimes I still go back to those memories but now I only feel disgust at him, not me. The remaining 99.9% of my time he’s nothing. He’s essentially irrelevant now.
This is something the courts need to be aware of. Ever since I discovered my ex’s true self, I have tried to explain to others that he married me under false pretenses–so he should not be entitled to any of the usual compensations in divorce–half of my pension, etc! I have maintained that had I known who and what he was, I would never have SPOKEN to him, let alone married him and had three children with him. And because of his deceit, I am supposed to let my minor child have visitation with him?? An embezzler and porn addict?? Not likely! Though, of course, I have had to engage in some of my own manipulation to prevent that from happening. The courts are woefully ignorant when it comes to sociopaths and parenting.
Good luck with the book–much needed!
Dear Donna:
This is the BEST news I have read on your site in a while. The fact is, if “emotional rape” isn’t currently a crime, it absolutely should be (and should have been, for some time now!). The “damage” done to one’s life (emotional health, physical health, financial well-being, future ability to trust, function, etc.) as a result of this despicable behavior/deceit/betrayal/manipulation is unlike anything that most currently “recognized” crimes cause. In my legal opinion, the damages are typically far worse in type, number and severity. As we all know, this type of victimization is on the uptick, as the number of these perpetrators in society increases. The legislatures and courts must acknowledge and respond NOW, not 10-20 years from now, when the wreckage wrought from these individuals creates a crisis of its own sociologically, economically, etc. I am so glad this book was written, and words cannot express how much admiration and gratitude I have for its author. Such a immensely courageous woman! Thank you!!!
Joyce, this sentence in your post spoke to me: “On-lookers who were not faced with the same neurologically induced connection to the predator may have been bewildered by our interest in remaining in the relationship.” I have never broken no contact with this man since the day he abandoned me and the relationship after he manipulated me and set me up so he could do the absolute most harm possible, almost 2 1/2 years ago. I’ve spent this time single mindedly working to clean up the mess he made of my life, and of me…and pretty much all of my “friends” have walked away from me because for once I was unable to be there for them and needed their support. The one “friend” who has marginally stayed in my life felt it necessary to continue her subtle jabs at me by sending me a whopper of an email on New Year’s Eve (just when I was feeling some hard earned optimism for the coming year) and gave me her opinion that I may be “wearing the victim dress” well as does her mother and that she was concerned that the reason I recently quit a part time job that wasn’t working for me was that I wanted to “hole myself up” in my house and shut out the world, but she wasn’t sure what “tape” I had playing in my head currently. Though nothing could be farther from the truth, I have both feet in the survivor camp and am more proud of this than anything I have accomplished in my life, I am still fragile enough for this to have thrown me into a day of extreme self doubt. Mind you, this person lives two states away and hasn’t seen me since the discard happened and we rarely talk on the phone…she has no idea really, who or how I am now. One of the hardest things to deal with over this time is how people just disappeared from my life or actively attacked me for how I was handling things, and almost no one valued me enough to listen and try to understand. I guess a by product of it all is that I now know what constitutes a true friend, and that none of these people were. I understand what happened to me and how, and I know it wasn’t my fault. I know who I am…and although I am still fragile, I have self respect and I’m almost out of the fire. In 2014 I will fully have my life back and I intend to get some new friends and live again.
LandLady-
Thanks so much for your words of support!
HanaleiMoon-
Your friends and family are simply not enlightened by the information you now know. They don’t grasp how “sucked in” and complex a predator’s web can be. And it’s rare that they understand the neurologic components of betrayal that created the toxic glue that kept you stuck.
It’s one of the reasons I decided to go public with my book. Victims rarely get the supportive validation that could help ease their pain. I address this in my final chapter.
Perhaps if you give them either my book, “Carnal Abuse by Deceit” or “The Betrayal Bond” by Dr. Carnes, they might begin to understand. Opinions are hard to change, but through this site and other similar ones, as well as the literature that is finally surfacing on these issues, society’s awareness will grow.
I wrote the following poem as I was going through the emotional upheaval of my friends and family not understanding. My sister had given me a gazillion reasons why I shouldn’t write the book as well as trying to convince me that I “made bad decisions” and “shouldn’t blame.” I hope it helps you find some solace.
Moving On
For those who don’t support my right
To end my pain by shedding light;
Their own agendas don’t embrace,
What’s best for me, their loss I face.
Life changes all along the way,
Some things move on while others stay,
But those who want what’s best for me,
Support my right to set me free.
So I speak out, and lay him bare,
That man who acts without a care,
His wretched actions hurt no more,
My power’s back, I’ve closed his door.
And even if he feigns protest,
My heart’s unbound, I’ve done my best.
My silence wasn’t his to hold,
My right to heal has made me bold.
All the best-
Joyce
Joyce, thank you so much for sharing your poem! I love it and have printed it out to keep at hand. I plan on getting your book for myself. Unfortunately, I can’t think of anyone in my life who would be willing to take their time to read it (over time I’ve shared some articles and other information and feel like it’s been glossed over or ignored). I sometimes feel that what we come to accept and understand as the hows and whys of what happened is seen by those who haven’t experienced it as an “excuse” for what they see as our “mistakes”. I’ve heard over and over again that it would never have happened to them…and that I need to take responsibility for what happened. This devastated me in the beginning since I was already reeling from the manipulations and drama created by the monster. But over time, finding books like yours and sites like this and becoming educated, I am needing understanding less and less. I’m looking forward to the future and new friends.
HanaleiMoon, your statement that in 2014 you will fully have your life back and you intend to get some new friends and live again resonated with me. I have been out of the relationship since May of 2010, and I am just now getting to that same point. All I can say is you go girl! I still have a ways to go, but every day is one day closer to being whole again. He is now just a blip on the timeline of my life, but the damage he did has taken some very intense work to try and repair and move on. As you stated, “One of the hardest things to deal with over this time is how people just disappeared from my life or actively attacked me for how I was handling things, and almost no one valued me enough to listen and try to understand.” This, I think is when I felt like I was perhaps the crazy one. But as those of us on this site know, that is what they want us to think. One of the worst things for me was that the large majority of those who treated me this way were those in our church. I literally sat in class silently, with tears streaming down my face, and not a single person ever asked what was wrong, not even in private. I went to church with bruises on my face, a broken arm, a broken tailbone, all on separate occasions, and not one single person ever asked any questions. This made it that much more difficult. I finally quit going to church because I couldn’t bare to watch the huge performance he gave every week. But all of that is the past, and I am finally easing into socializing and doing some enjoyable things again. What a great feeling it is. However, sometimes I still have to remind myself to just breathe and enjoy life. Yeah 2014!!!
Part of why the courts don’t recognize this type of thing, is that many involved in the court system are narcissists and sociopaths (Statement made by my attorney).
HA! So true!!
A lot of convicted paedophiles have had high powered jobs in england-magistrates,police,m.p.s,justices of the peace, teachers,
social workers.(evidence online)