Editor’s note: At the request of readers, the Lovefraud member “Skylar” has contributed the following article.
When dealing with malignant narcissists, psychopaths, sociopaths, borderlines, drama queens, stalkers and other emotional vampires, it’s commonly advised that no response is the best response to unwanted attention. This is often true and No Contact (the avoidance of all communication) should be used whenever possible.
There are some situations however, when No Contact is not feasible, as in when you share child custody with a psychopath. As another example, if you are being stalked by an ex, a restraining order can infuriate the unwanted suitor, and refusing to respond to him or her is seen as an insult. They might become convinced that they can MAKE you respond and in that way satiate their need for power over you.
Furthermore, many of us have tried to end a relationship with a psychopath several times, only to take them back, each time. They turned on the pity ploy and the charm, and because we didn’t understand that this is what a psychopath does, we fell for their promises to change. They know all of our emotional hooks. For them, it’s easy and fun to lure us back by appealing to our emotions. But a psychopath can’t change. In fact, when you leave a psychopath, he becomes determined to punish you even more severely for thinking you could be autonomous.
Even if we don’t take them back, the most dangerous time for a person is when they first break up with a psychopath. The psychopath feels rage at being discarded. Losing control or power over a person is not just a narcissistic injury for them; they feel profoundly empty when their partner leaves them even if they had intended to kill their partner. The reason is because they have lost control. Psychopaths need to feel in control at all times.
For all these situations, we have Gray Rock.
What it is:
So, how do we escape this parasitical leech without triggering his vindictive rage? Gray Rock is primarily a way of encouraging a psychopath, a stalker or other emotionally unbalanced person, to lose interest in you. It differs from No Contact in that you don’t overtly try to avoid contact with these emotional vampires. Instead, you allow contact but only give boring, monotonous responses so that the parasite must go elsewhere for his supply of drama. When contact with you is consistently unsatisfying for the psychopath, his mind is re-trained to expect boredom rather than drama. Psychopaths are addicted to drama and they can’t stand to be bored. With time, he will find a new person to provide drama and he will find himself drawn to you less and less often. Eventually, they just slither away to greener pastures. Gray Rock is a way of training the psychopath to view you as an unsatisfying pursuit you bore him and he can’t stand boredom.
What it’s for:
Making a psychopath go away of his own volition is one application of Gray Rock. One might say that Gray Rock is a way of breaking up with a psychopath by using the old, “It’s not you, it’s me.” excuse, except that you act it out instead of saying it and the psychopath comes to that conclusion on his own.
Another reason to use Gray Rock is to avoid becoming a target in the first place. If you find yourself in the company of one or more narcissistic personalities perhaps you work with them or they are members of your family it’s important to avoid triggering their ENVY. By using Gray Rock, you fade into the background. It’s possible they won’t even remember having met you. If you have already inadvertently attracted their attention and they have already begun to focus in on you, you can still use Gray Rock. Tell them you are boring. Describe a boring life. Talk about the most mundane household chores you accomplished that day in detail. Some people are naturally lacking in dramatic flair. Find those people and try to hang around them when the psychopath is nearby.
If you must continue a relationship with a psychopath, Gray Rock can serve you as well. Parents sharing joint custody with a psychopathic ex-spouse can use Gray Rock when the ex-spouse tries to trigger their emotions. I acknowledge that any threat to the well-being of our children is overwhelmingly anxiety provoking. Here is where Gray Rock can be applied selectively to draw attention away from what really matters to you. In general, show no emotion to the offending behaviors or words. The psychopath will try different tactics to see which ones get a reaction. With Selective Gray Rock, you choose to respond to the tactic which matters least to you. This will focus the psychopath’s attention on that issue. Remember, the psychopath has no values, so he doesn’t understand what is valuable to us unless we show him. Selective Gray Rock shows him a decoy. When protecting our children, we can take a lesson from nature: Bird parents who have fledglings are known to feign a broken wing when a predator is in the vicinity. They fake a vulnerability to detract the cat’s attention from their real vulnerability, their babies. In this example, Selective Gray Rock fades all emotions into the background except the ones you want the predator to see.
Why it works:
A psychopath is easily bored. He or she needs constant stimulation to ward off boredom. It isn’t the type of boredom that normal people experience; it’s more like the French word, ennui, which refers to an oppressive boredom or listlessness. Drama is a psychopath’s remedy for boredom. For drama, they need an audience and some players. Once the drama begins, they feel complete and alive again. They are empowered when pulling the strings that elicit our emotions. Any kind of emotions will do, as long as it is a response to their actions.
A psychopath is an addict. He is addicted to power. His power is acquired by gaining access to our emotions. He is keenly aware of this and needs to constantly test to make sure we are still under his control. He needs to know that we are still eager to do his bidding, make him happy and avoid his wrath. He needs to create drama so he can experience the power of manipulating our emotions. As with any addiction, it is exhilarating to the psychopath when he gets his supply of emotional responses. The more times he experiences a reward for his dramatic behavior, the more addicted he becomes. Conversely, when the reward stops coming, he becomes agitated. He experiences oppressive boredom and he will counter it by creating more drama. If we stay the course and show no emotions, the psychopath will eventually decide that his toy is broken. It doesn’t squirt emotions when he squeezes it anymore! Most likely, he will slither away to find a new toy.
The Gray Rock technique does come with a caveat: psychopaths are dangerous people, if you are in a relationship with one that has already decided to kill you, it will be difficult to change his mind. He may already be poisoning you or sabotaging your vehicle. Take all necessary precautions. In this case, Gray Rock can only hope to buy time until you can make your escape.
How it works:
Psychopaths are attracted to shiny, pretty things that move fast and to bright lights. These things, signal excitement and relieve the psychopath’s ever-present ennui. Your emotional responses are his food of choice, but they aren’t the only things he wants.
He envies everything pretty, shiny and sparkly that you have and he wants whatever you value. You must hide anything that he will notice and envy. If you happen to be very good looking, you need to change that during this time. Use makeup to add bags under your eyes. If you aren’t married to the psychopath, any money or assets he covets should disappear “in a bad investment decision” (consult with your attorney on this). Your shiny sports car has to go, get a beater. If you have a sparkling reputation, anticipate that he will or has already begun to slander you; therefore, don’t allow yourself to be put into any compromising position or pushed into erratic behavior. The reason he wants to take these things from you, is not necessarily because he wants them for himself, it’s because he wants to see the emotions on your face when you lose them. He wants the power trip associated with being the one who took them from you. By preemptively removing these things from his vision and not reacting with emotion at the losses, you continue to train him with the idea that you are the most boring person on earth, someone he would never want to be.
Origin of Gray Rock:
In 2009, I left my psychopathic partner after 25 years, but I didn’t understand what was wrong with him. I sat in a sushi bar, lost in confusion, when a tall, athletic man introduced himself. To my own surprise, I instinctively poured out my story to him. This complete stranger listened to my story and then he explained to me that I was dealing with a malignant narcissist. He advised me, “Be boring.” He told me that his girlfriend would come home each night, begin drinking and become abusive. They were both professionals who traveled in the same professional circles. He knew that she would stalk him if he broke up with her and he didn’t want to risk the slander and drama which could leak out and damage his professional reputation.
His solution was to be so boring that she would simply leave him. He declined to go out on evenings and weekends. He showed no emotional reaction about anything, no interest in anything and responded with no drama. When she asked if he wanted to go out for dinner, his reply was, “I don’t know.” After a few months of no drama, she simply moved out.
Why is it called Gray Rock?
I chose the words Gray Rock because I needed an object for us to channel when we are in an emotionally charged situation. You don’t just practice Gray Rock, you BECOME a Gray Rock. There are gray rocks and pebbles everywhere you go, but you never notice them. None of them attract your attention. You don’t remember any specific rock you saw today because they blend with the scenery. That is the type of boring that you want to channel when you are dealing with a psychopath. Your boring persona will camouflage you and the psychopath won’t even notice you were there. The stranger in the sushi bar showed great insight when he advised me to “be boring.” He struck at the heart of the psychopath’s motivation: to avoid boredom.
In nature, there are many plants and creatures that show us how to survive in a world of predators. Among others, birds feign injury to protect their babies and mice play dead until the cat loses interest. Both of these tactics can be useful and they can be channeled when applicable. Yet, it’s difficult to calculate each and every move that a psychopath will make and to determine the best course of action each time. Instead of trying to out-think him, channel the gray rock. This simple, humble object in nature has all the wisdom it needs to avoid being noticed, it’s boring.
Copyright © 2012 Skylar
My comment to G1S about the spath trying to destroy everything, even my faith in God, gave me insight about something he did.
I’ve always suspected he killed my favorite cat, Julian. The look on his face when he told me that he found Julian dead on the road, gave me the creeps. It was fake crying and I could tell. So after he was unmasked I knew he had done it and I assumed it was to make me sad and hurt. But now I know that’s not the entire reason.
About a week before Julian’s death, Spath said to me, “Skylar, I worry so much about our kitties and I hope nothing ever happens to them. But I can’t pray to God to ask Him to protect them, because God doesn’t answer my prayers. You are going to have to pray for them.” He went on and on about it.
Today I realized that he wanted me to pray and so that the death of Julian would convince me that God doesn’t answer my prayers. He was trying to separate me from my faith.
The idiot spath thinks people pray the way spaths pray. Spaths pray, “God give me what I want.” Normal people pray, “Thy will be done.”
As I reflected on the words that the spath chose in this particular deception, I could see the partial truths and the Freudian slips. He really does believe that God doesn’t answer his prayers. The prayer he wrote to God, asked for healing from his evil but he only got worse after that.
Furthermore, he could see God answering my prayers all the time in my life through miracles and my general gratitude. It must have driven him crazy with envy. He had to try to take away my faith by getting me to pray for the safety of the kitties and then killing my favorite one.
I get it now.
Skylar,
What an absolutely BRILLIANT article!! Thank you so much for writing it out so clearly for us. It’s so empowering and gives me hope that I could actually do it when I doubted I could control my feelings before. Now it’s so clear, I can’t wait to try it!
Wow, Sky! What an insight you got about it: he was trying to make you lose your faith by killing a pet you loved. Loss can indeed make people question their faith or be angry at God or the faiths or life, whichever concept you give power outside yourself. But it’s also true that faith is not so much about “wanting stuff or objects or events” in a magical way. It’s about understanding, wisdom and gratefuluness about what you do have, and the ability to bear the losses.
I think that Lovefraud is especially healing regarding coming to understand such spath ploys in our past relationships. I have tried once or twice to explain such an insight to my mother, but for her it seems too far fetched to suppose his chaotic behaviour could have been intentional. She sees it as the indavertent result of unintentional chaotic carelesness. And so does my best friend. That even this can be an act or a mask to hide behind while being intentionally destructive is I realize one bridge too much for both of them to cross. Actually, I think my dad is more able to understand it. When I brought up the car-accident lie to him a couple of months ago, he instantly said, before I could give my conclusion, “He was setting up a stage to make you look like a liar.” But he gets very much upset when reminded that someone wanted to hurt his daughter. Lovefraud is the sole place where I can express the A-HA moments I have about some event or behaviour.
Eleanor,
you CAN do it. If you need pointers, Milo and 20-years are our resident experts on it.
Darwinsmom,
yes it’s a mind-fuck. My spath had a certain pattern of tells. I could see something was off, when he spoke a certain way, but could never imagine what it meant.
Even now, it is a slow process putting it together because normal people simply don’t do that and my mind doesn’t “click” with each memory – it’s a slow, dawning realization.
I had already come to that conclusion with Rainbow, another kitty he killed. Before her disappearance, he said, “I saw the BIGGEST coyote I’ve ever seen hiding in the bushes next to the house. I stared at it and it stared back. It wasn’t afraid of me at all!” Lies.
Not only do coyotes not run around during the day, but none of them stare at you, they run. I had long accepted that he killed Rainbow. It appeared that she had been eaten by coyotes as nothing was found of her except the tracking device and it had been “chewed” on both sides and it had “chew marks on it”. But here’s the tip off. I cleaned the tracking device BEFORE she was killed and it had chew marks on it then too. I remembered.
Sky-I’m jumping in here off topic hoping you are around. I read your reply to my pitty party last night. Your last comment was about gray rocking. You said it was best if everyone does it. Well, my N/P is playing the good one with the kids these days so…. . When the onechild gets in his moods itry to get the others to gray rock him but the young ones just can’t do it. As for me I’d say I’d earn a B in gray rocking but that 10% I mess up is 100% victory for him (I’m talking about the N/P not my son). Feeling a little bit better tonight but I spent most the day crying. He is still lingering around and that really messes with my mind these days.
Skylar,
I said from the very beginning, when I realized how coordinated the attack was against me, that it was all about my P sister’s jealousy.
My S mother had elevated her to perfect. When I was diagnosed with breast cancer during my pregancy, which is a long story in itself, I ended up living with my parents the last few months of my pregnancy – partially because my P sister threw me out of her place because I wasn’t being supportive of the distress she was going through over my being pregnant and having cancer. My son and I stayed with my parents about four years.
During that time, my S mother got to know me and decided not only wasn’t I that bad, but my friends impressed her and neither of my parents could say enough praise about my son. That’s when my P sister started with the comments, “How come nobody ever praises my daughter?” (Her daughter would ultimately be diagnosed with borderline personality disorder, but since she was young back then, she went from brat to being a first-class, b*tchy teen.)
Because of my cancer and pregnancy interrupted my career and the economy was horrible, finding work was extremely difficult. My parents loaned me money, but more importantly, my parents welcomed our presence and would have been happy if we had stayed.
That’s when my mother started saying things like, “I think the off-spring who stays home to help the parents in their twilight years should inherit the bulk of the parents’ estate because they sacrifice so much to stay with the parents. They never get a chance to build a nestegg for themselves and they pass on having a family of their own.”
My mother must have said something about that to my P sister because one day, the P growled to me that I was cutting into her inheritance. Never mind that she had been making over six figures for years and that her McMansion was fully paid before they finished building it. And, her significant other was contributing subtantially to their household as well. (I was on welfare when I was sick during my pregnancy – out of work and no health insurance. Paid rent, though, and fed ourselves via food stamps and WIC.)
What my P sister wanted to do was push me in the gutter to die, figuratively speaking, although that is what she told my son would literally happen because I was so crazy I wouldn’t sell my starter home to pay back the money my parents had loaned me and move into an apartment. She later told me that those loans were all the inheritance that I would ever get.
Anyway, not only was she intent on seeing me die, but she wanted to steal my son to show the world that she could be the better mother.
It was all about envy. She had lost her elevated, exclusive place in my mother’s eyes, my parents were loaning me and there was a real threat that I would get much more, and EVERYBODY commented how that my son was such a sweet, loving, and funny boy.
The green-eyed monster is not just an expression; it’s much more of a monster than most realize.
Justus,
with little kids you really have your work cut out for you because I can’t imagine that they will be able to react to the love bomb, with a gray rock.
yes the 10% that you gave him is enough to feed and encourage him. He has learned that 1 out of 10 times he succeeds.
The trick, I think is to actually BE boring, don’t act boring. Milo has some good stories about her successes. She doesn’t act sleepy, she uses platitudes and niceties. In fact, she’s always nice to her daughter no matter what but not in an emotional way. She is polite, non-committal, disinterested. The way you would be with a stranger at work.
With your little kids, I would worry that they would disclose your gray rock strategy to your spath. I wouldn’t worry too much about their ability to gray rock because the person he is really addicted to, is you.
G1S,
I don’t know your story very well but I gather from your referral to her as your S-mother, that she is also disordered.
From my experience in my own family and also from my reading, I would say that your mother is seeding your sister’s envy against you. She is creating a triangle so that your sister and you will fight over her. Your sister, I’m sure, is a P and wants you dead, (as mine does, me) but it is mostly derived from your mom’s desire for her to hate you.
So, what I’m saying is that it might have appeared that your mom was elevating you on to the pedestal, but that was just for show. The only one on the pedestal is your mother.
The circumstances which brought you to her home needing her help, were similar to mine when I ran from my ex-spath. My spath sister became even more envious than ever. Ironically, she was unknowingly conspiring with my ex-spath in his plan to make me commit suicide. (her husband is a planted trojan horse which my spath sent into my family, but spath sister doesn’t believe it – though I’ve now told her)
When I moved back in with my parents, they knew that their plan had backfired. What she wants more than anything is to climb back into my mother’s womb and I had taken a step in that direction by moving back into my mother’s home.
As it turned out, I realized that both my parents are spath (as is my 47 year old brother that they keep in the basement) and I moved out soon after.
You would really benefit from the book, “why is it always about you?” by sandy hotchkiss. It’s all about envy and slime and how it comes about.
This behavior is not really unusual, to my surprise. Lots of parents pit their kids into sibling rivalry. Just look at the Kennedy clan. It can cause all kinds of sick behaviors for the rest of the adult children’s lives and even into their kids too.
You might find this article validating:
http://parrishmiller.com/narcissists.html
Skylar,
I just wrote a long response to you, but lost it when I clicked on the RSS Feed for this Entry below.
I don’t have the time to write any more now. I will try to recreate my response later.
Thanks for the reading suggestions. I was not aware of those.
Skylar and G1S,
Thank you for the book suggestions. I’ve ordered “Strong at the Broken Places”, and last night for Valentine’s my husband brought home chocolates, flowers, and the book “Why is it Always about YOU?”!!! If that isn’t love I don’t know what is… 😉 But I imagine that would look pre-e-e-e-tty bad to anyone who didn’t know the back story!
Sky, the article in the link you posted was another one of those major influences that changed my life. If they’d included physical violence and torture (and had a little more emphasis on the mindf**k) it pretty much nails my mother.
Two more articles on the subject (one is part of a series) that I found helpful are here:
http://www.darksouls-thebook.com/the-scapegoat.html
http://www.kellevision.com/kellevision/2008/11/the-scapegoat.html