Editor’s note: At the request of readers, the Lovefraud member “Skylar” has contributed the following article.
When dealing with malignant narcissists, psychopaths, sociopaths, borderlines, drama queens, stalkers and other emotional vampires, it’s commonly advised that no response is the best response to unwanted attention. This is often true and No Contact (the avoidance of all communication) should be used whenever possible.
There are some situations however, when No Contact is not feasible, as in when you share child custody with a psychopath. As another example, if you are being stalked by an ex, a restraining order can infuriate the unwanted suitor, and refusing to respond to him or her is seen as an insult. They might become convinced that they can MAKE you respond and in that way satiate their need for power over you.
Furthermore, many of us have tried to end a relationship with a psychopath several times, only to take them back, each time. They turned on the pity ploy and the charm, and because we didn’t understand that this is what a psychopath does, we fell for their promises to change. They know all of our emotional hooks. For them, it’s easy and fun to lure us back by appealing to our emotions. But a psychopath can’t change. In fact, when you leave a psychopath, he becomes determined to punish you even more severely for thinking you could be autonomous.
Even if we don’t take them back, the most dangerous time for a person is when they first break up with a psychopath. The psychopath feels rage at being discarded. Losing control or power over a person is not just a narcissistic injury for them; they feel profoundly empty when their partner leaves them even if they had intended to kill their partner. The reason is because they have lost control. Psychopaths need to feel in control at all times.
For all these situations, we have Gray Rock.
What it is:
So, how do we escape this parasitical leech without triggering his vindictive rage? Gray Rock is primarily a way of encouraging a psychopath, a stalker or other emotionally unbalanced person, to lose interest in you. It differs from No Contact in that you don’t overtly try to avoid contact with these emotional vampires. Instead, you allow contact but only give boring, monotonous responses so that the parasite must go elsewhere for his supply of drama. When contact with you is consistently unsatisfying for the psychopath, his mind is re-trained to expect boredom rather than drama. Psychopaths are addicted to drama and they can’t stand to be bored. With time, he will find a new person to provide drama and he will find himself drawn to you less and less often. Eventually, they just slither away to greener pastures. Gray Rock is a way of training the psychopath to view you as an unsatisfying pursuit you bore him and he can’t stand boredom.
What it’s for:
Making a psychopath go away of his own volition is one application of Gray Rock. One might say that Gray Rock is a way of breaking up with a psychopath by using the old, “It’s not you, it’s me.” excuse, except that you act it out instead of saying it and the psychopath comes to that conclusion on his own.
Another reason to use Gray Rock is to avoid becoming a target in the first place. If you find yourself in the company of one or more narcissistic personalities perhaps you work with them or they are members of your family it’s important to avoid triggering their ENVY. By using Gray Rock, you fade into the background. It’s possible they won’t even remember having met you. If you have already inadvertently attracted their attention and they have already begun to focus in on you, you can still use Gray Rock. Tell them you are boring. Describe a boring life. Talk about the most mundane household chores you accomplished that day in detail. Some people are naturally lacking in dramatic flair. Find those people and try to hang around them when the psychopath is nearby.
If you must continue a relationship with a psychopath, Gray Rock can serve you as well. Parents sharing joint custody with a psychopathic ex-spouse can use Gray Rock when the ex-spouse tries to trigger their emotions. I acknowledge that any threat to the well-being of our children is overwhelmingly anxiety provoking. Here is where Gray Rock can be applied selectively to draw attention away from what really matters to you. In general, show no emotion to the offending behaviors or words. The psychopath will try different tactics to see which ones get a reaction. With Selective Gray Rock, you choose to respond to the tactic which matters least to you. This will focus the psychopath’s attention on that issue. Remember, the psychopath has no values, so he doesn’t understand what is valuable to us unless we show him. Selective Gray Rock shows him a decoy. When protecting our children, we can take a lesson from nature: Bird parents who have fledglings are known to feign a broken wing when a predator is in the vicinity. They fake a vulnerability to detract the cat’s attention from their real vulnerability, their babies. In this example, Selective Gray Rock fades all emotions into the background except the ones you want the predator to see.
Why it works:
A psychopath is easily bored. He or she needs constant stimulation to ward off boredom. It isn’t the type of boredom that normal people experience; it’s more like the French word, ennui, which refers to an oppressive boredom or listlessness. Drama is a psychopath’s remedy for boredom. For drama, they need an audience and some players. Once the drama begins, they feel complete and alive again. They are empowered when pulling the strings that elicit our emotions. Any kind of emotions will do, as long as it is a response to their actions.
A psychopath is an addict. He is addicted to power. His power is acquired by gaining access to our emotions. He is keenly aware of this and needs to constantly test to make sure we are still under his control. He needs to know that we are still eager to do his bidding, make him happy and avoid his wrath. He needs to create drama so he can experience the power of manipulating our emotions. As with any addiction, it is exhilarating to the psychopath when he gets his supply of emotional responses. The more times he experiences a reward for his dramatic behavior, the more addicted he becomes. Conversely, when the reward stops coming, he becomes agitated. He experiences oppressive boredom and he will counter it by creating more drama. If we stay the course and show no emotions, the psychopath will eventually decide that his toy is broken. It doesn’t squirt emotions when he squeezes it anymore! Most likely, he will slither away to find a new toy.
The Gray Rock technique does come with a caveat: psychopaths are dangerous people, if you are in a relationship with one that has already decided to kill you, it will be difficult to change his mind. He may already be poisoning you or sabotaging your vehicle. Take all necessary precautions. In this case, Gray Rock can only hope to buy time until you can make your escape.
How it works:
Psychopaths are attracted to shiny, pretty things that move fast and to bright lights. These things, signal excitement and relieve the psychopath’s ever-present ennui. Your emotional responses are his food of choice, but they aren’t the only things he wants.
He envies everything pretty, shiny and sparkly that you have and he wants whatever you value. You must hide anything that he will notice and envy. If you happen to be very good looking, you need to change that during this time. Use makeup to add bags under your eyes. If you aren’t married to the psychopath, any money or assets he covets should disappear “in a bad investment decision” (consult with your attorney on this). Your shiny sports car has to go, get a beater. If you have a sparkling reputation, anticipate that he will or has already begun to slander you; therefore, don’t allow yourself to be put into any compromising position or pushed into erratic behavior. The reason he wants to take these things from you, is not necessarily because he wants them for himself, it’s because he wants to see the emotions on your face when you lose them. He wants the power trip associated with being the one who took them from you. By preemptively removing these things from his vision and not reacting with emotion at the losses, you continue to train him with the idea that you are the most boring person on earth, someone he would never want to be.
Origin of Gray Rock:
In 2009, I left my psychopathic partner after 25 years, but I didn’t understand what was wrong with him. I sat in a sushi bar, lost in confusion, when a tall, athletic man introduced himself. To my own surprise, I instinctively poured out my story to him. This complete stranger listened to my story and then he explained to me that I was dealing with a malignant narcissist. He advised me, “Be boring.” He told me that his girlfriend would come home each night, begin drinking and become abusive. They were both professionals who traveled in the same professional circles. He knew that she would stalk him if he broke up with her and he didn’t want to risk the slander and drama which could leak out and damage his professional reputation.
His solution was to be so boring that she would simply leave him. He declined to go out on evenings and weekends. He showed no emotional reaction about anything, no interest in anything and responded with no drama. When she asked if he wanted to go out for dinner, his reply was, “I don’t know.” After a few months of no drama, she simply moved out.
Why is it called Gray Rock?
I chose the words Gray Rock because I needed an object for us to channel when we are in an emotionally charged situation. You don’t just practice Gray Rock, you BECOME a Gray Rock. There are gray rocks and pebbles everywhere you go, but you never notice them. None of them attract your attention. You don’t remember any specific rock you saw today because they blend with the scenery. That is the type of boring that you want to channel when you are dealing with a psychopath. Your boring persona will camouflage you and the psychopath won’t even notice you were there. The stranger in the sushi bar showed great insight when he advised me to “be boring.” He struck at the heart of the psychopath’s motivation: to avoid boredom.
In nature, there are many plants and creatures that show us how to survive in a world of predators. Among others, birds feign injury to protect their babies and mice play dead until the cat loses interest. Both of these tactics can be useful and they can be channeled when applicable. Yet, it’s difficult to calculate each and every move that a psychopath will make and to determine the best course of action each time. Instead of trying to out-think him, channel the gray rock. This simple, humble object in nature has all the wisdom it needs to avoid being noticed, it’s boring.
Copyright © 2012 Skylar
Skylar,
Thanks so much for writing this. What a great contribution you’ve made to everyone who reads here.
I agree with previous posters – what you’ve said is so much more understandable and *useful* than the advice you get from people who’ve never been there.
Let’s all raise our glasses in thanks to the helpful stranger Sky met in that sushi bar, and to Skylar for developing her gray rock theory and sharing it with us here!
Edit: Wanted to add that I particularly appreciated the section about envy. Really eye-opening and very helpful.
I don’t have to know why they do anything they do because it is an enigma, even unto them, I think. Truly.
But I do have to know when not to keep hurting myself.
It has reached OVER it’s limitation with me now.
It’s a horrid realization that someone you thought was your best friend was actually loving you, smiling at you, while secretly wanting to murder you in cold blood. How chilling is that?
THEN, on top of that shocking reality, I had a massive heart attack that almost took my life. So I have been dealing with two demons at once. One had to go and it isn’t going to be my heart. MY ACTUAL HEART lives inside my chest and keeps me alive. I am not sacrificing that for this or anything else anymore.
As Annie said: “Let’s all raise our glasses in thanks to the helpful stranger sky met in that sushi bar, and to skylar for developing her gray rock theory and sharing it with us here!”
I’ll drink to that. From the first instance I heard you talk about it sky, I knew exactly what you were meaning and it helped me more than A LOT. I shall forever be grateful to you for your sharing and insight.
I am safe now. There will be no more threats and no more attempts. Not ever. Simply because he isn’t allowed anywhere near me anymore or he will be arrested. THAT is a fact now. If he would like to ‘try it out’, like he has in the past, and been met with great dismay at his failed attempts, he can be my guest to try. I am not afraid of him anymore. He has been neutralized.
skylar: thank you, with love.
Dupey
Wow, Sky, was doing chores and came back to the computer to find this article! Glad you posted it. Gray rock does work in some situations….in others ANY contact, even boring contact will “lead them on”—-so I would ONLY use it if NO CONTACT is not a legal option…or in the early stages of planning to get away from one…so you don’t rouse their suspicions.
They DO LOVE THE DRAMA and if we do not do drama with them, if we do not let the PLOT THICKEN by adding our own emotions to the plot, it helps to calm them down many times. Some are worse than others though….and it is difficult to hold on to the POKER FACE when they are using your kid for chips!
Glad you finally got around to posting this in an article form! Good JOB!!!! TOWANDA!!!!!
Skylar~ This post is FANTASTIC!!! Although I have heard the term “grey rock” used on LF many times I never knew it originated from you. It’s absolutely brilliant and I do know it WORKS!!!
Initially after leaving my spath I was in so much emotional pain that I would call him up and scream obscenities to him over and over again. I would pour out my soul over and over trying to make him see how much he had hurt me….always so confused as to why he could not FEEL my pain.
A couple months after I joined LF; Ox Drover made me see that NC was really the best way ~ and it worked!! But on those occasions that I did have to have some sort of contact with him I would only give him one word (or very vague) answers. I noticed he would either try kindess or meaness to get to me at various times….and even though I wanted to “strike back” I would remember the wise words “grey rock”.
Sometimes my children will tell me how absolutely frustrated they are with the exs drama. I am printing out this article and giving each of them a copy. There is no better way to explain it than in plain old black and white with their own two (four) eyes!!
AND OUR LOVE FRAUD WORD OF THE WEEK IS:
::::ENIGMA::::
🙂
Thinking about how I was able to make use of “gray rock” about halfway through that danged CPS-mandated therapy with my ex-husband, his wife and the three children… seriously, it was like a switch flipped in my brain, and I am forever grateful to you for introducing me to this concept.
Actually, what was so excellent, now that I can think back on the experience of suddenly getting it, was that I did literally spend the first 2 months of the therapy trying to do what I thought I was supposed to do: “express feelings” (sometimes “with feeling” and sometimes just saying, “I feel…..”) but what ended up happening was that whenever I would express a feeling, the spath and spathwife would get a visible GLEAM in their eyes, and then they would zero in on it, somehow, having discovered something I desired that they could thwart, or something I dreaded, that they could provide. But I couldn’t figure out how to “do” therapy without expressing feelings!
(I am now flashing back to the awful memories of the failed marriage therapy with my ex-husband… and the instructions from the therapists (seven of them!) for us to use “I-messages” you know, where you say something like “when you smashed your fist through the wall, I felt scared…” or “when you said ‘that was a terrible dinner’ I felt sad, because I had wanted you to like it and I tried hard to make something good…” and those I-messages are supposed to help improve your communication and your relationship, because they can see it from your perspective. I tried SO HARD and I can still see his face when I tried to do one of those I-messages” and he rolled his eyes with derision and his lip curled in contempt at my sincere desire and attempt to work things out with him…oh, ick! I’m so glad that is over)
Anyway, this is a long-winded way of saying, I think there are a lot of therapists who do not get this. And so, halfway through the recent forced therapy, I “got” GRAY ROCK and started being very bland, boring and somewhat absent minded… I might start to say something (exciting) then I’d suddenly remember (GRAY ROCK!) and I’d get a faraway look and sort of trail off and then kind of say…. “oh, I can’t remember (sigh)…”
and it is very interesting to me now, to reflect back how disconcerted spath and spathwife suddenly got, in the therapy. I certainly no longer provided any supply to them. I just really didn’t have a whole lot to say about much of anything.
They tried to bait me a few times, and I turned it back on them. The bait was that they were “disappointed” in me or “concerned about the safety of the children in my house” and so I’d just listen and sympathize along with them, how disappointed or concerned they must be, and how understandable it all was, from their perspective…
THANKS, SKYLAR. You really helped our family! Gray Rock is like an invisible, protective cloak. It works best because it is invisible. (I think it changes our energy but they can’t quite put their finger on what’s different). The way I see the energy change is that before they could plug into us, like into an outlet, and either send bad stuff into us, or suck lifeforce out of us (that depleted feeling). But Gray Rock gets in the way — barrier protection! 🙂 It just diminishes their pleasure, doesn’t it. They can’t get through, and they don’t know why.
Dupey, I think the indifference is on its way! There is just some residual pain that is still working its way out (and tough because I see the pain the kids are being put through). But I think it is almost done. 🙂
Totally love it, Sky!!!
20 years ~ I know that gleam you were talking about. I saw it several times along with the “smirk” on the face as I am sobbing my eyes out. Hard to believe I could have loved someone so sick.
Skylar,
Thanks again for sharing your wisdom and insight.
Gray rock just didn’t work that well for me. I had to go NC. Spath saw even gray rock as an opening… and truthfully I hated what gray rock did to ME. Gray rock made ME feel like I was game playing, not being honest – probably also why it didn’t work. I’m not so good with a mask. That sucker always slips!!
what did I learn on here today? Well, for as long as I can remember my MIL has complained of insomnia. My ex spath did for awhile too but I guess he finally got that mostly corrected. (One of his improvements)
The jealousy and envy, yep, I sure did notice that with spath and MIL. They hate for something good to happen to you. They’re jealous of attention.
20 years Be glad you only spent the first 2 months of the therapy trying to do what I thought I was supposed to do: (I spent almost the entire marriage. Went at 2 years, 13, 15,18, and 20 years before I threw in the towel )
“express feelings” (sometimes “with feeling” and sometimes just saying, “I feel”..”) he would zero in on it, somehow, having discovered something I desired that he could thwart, or something I dreaded, that he could provide. But I couldn’t figure out how to “do” therapy without expressing feelings!
No wonder 5 counselors over the course of my marriage made so little difference. I became more tolerant and understanding, kept thinking if I just try harder… and the counselors I believe had NO IDEA what they were dealing with.
20years,
I messages are great way of communication with NORMAL people who are empathic. It does NOT WORK at all with spaths, but indeed points them the way on how to hurt you even more.
Relationship therapy is for NORMAL people who have issues about communication. But between an abuser and his or her victim it just gives the abuser more amunition.
The problem is that especially relationship therapists are not aware enough about trauma-bonding and what a spath actually craves from people and is out to get. It’s even understandable: relationship therapists start out therapy from the premisse that there are two normal healthy non-pathological persons sitting in front of them who need help communicating and sharing their feelings. They are trained in helping a relationship, not treating abuse victims, not treating abusers. However, since a lot of the abuse, especially emotional and mental, is not something easily evidenced for the law between adults, chances are VERY high that they end up counseling in an abusive relationship. So they ought to get training in spotting it.
Another problem imo is that for example my ex-spath was superb in delivering a perfect I-message. So, for a relationship therapist it would sound like that one party can express their issues exactly as it should be and thus must be healthy, and the victim is the one with the communication issues and therefore the problem in their eyes.