Editor’s note: At the request of readers, the Lovefraud member “Skylar” has contributed the following article.
When dealing with malignant narcissists, psychopaths, sociopaths, borderlines, drama queens, stalkers and other emotional vampires, it’s commonly advised that no response is the best response to unwanted attention. This is often true and No Contact (the avoidance of all communication) should be used whenever possible.
There are some situations however, when No Contact is not feasible, as in when you share child custody with a psychopath. As another example, if you are being stalked by an ex, a restraining order can infuriate the unwanted suitor, and refusing to respond to him or her is seen as an insult. They might become convinced that they can MAKE you respond and in that way satiate their need for power over you.
Furthermore, many of us have tried to end a relationship with a psychopath several times, only to take them back, each time. They turned on the pity ploy and the charm, and because we didn’t understand that this is what a psychopath does, we fell for their promises to change. They know all of our emotional hooks. For them, it’s easy and fun to lure us back by appealing to our emotions. But a psychopath can’t change. In fact, when you leave a psychopath, he becomes determined to punish you even more severely for thinking you could be autonomous.
Even if we don’t take them back, the most dangerous time for a person is when they first break up with a psychopath. The psychopath feels rage at being discarded. Losing control or power over a person is not just a narcissistic injury for them; they feel profoundly empty when their partner leaves them even if they had intended to kill their partner. The reason is because they have lost control. Psychopaths need to feel in control at all times.
For all these situations, we have Gray Rock.
What it is:
So, how do we escape this parasitical leech without triggering his vindictive rage? Gray Rock is primarily a way of encouraging a psychopath, a stalker or other emotionally unbalanced person, to lose interest in you. It differs from No Contact in that you don’t overtly try to avoid contact with these emotional vampires. Instead, you allow contact but only give boring, monotonous responses so that the parasite must go elsewhere for his supply of drama. When contact with you is consistently unsatisfying for the psychopath, his mind is re-trained to expect boredom rather than drama. Psychopaths are addicted to drama and they can’t stand to be bored. With time, he will find a new person to provide drama and he will find himself drawn to you less and less often. Eventually, they just slither away to greener pastures. Gray Rock is a way of training the psychopath to view you as an unsatisfying pursuit you bore him and he can’t stand boredom.
What it’s for:
Making a psychopath go away of his own volition is one application of Gray Rock. One might say that Gray Rock is a way of breaking up with a psychopath by using the old, “It’s not you, it’s me.” excuse, except that you act it out instead of saying it and the psychopath comes to that conclusion on his own.
Another reason to use Gray Rock is to avoid becoming a target in the first place. If you find yourself in the company of one or more narcissistic personalities perhaps you work with them or they are members of your family it’s important to avoid triggering their ENVY. By using Gray Rock, you fade into the background. It’s possible they won’t even remember having met you. If you have already inadvertently attracted their attention and they have already begun to focus in on you, you can still use Gray Rock. Tell them you are boring. Describe a boring life. Talk about the most mundane household chores you accomplished that day in detail. Some people are naturally lacking in dramatic flair. Find those people and try to hang around them when the psychopath is nearby.
If you must continue a relationship with a psychopath, Gray Rock can serve you as well. Parents sharing joint custody with a psychopathic ex-spouse can use Gray Rock when the ex-spouse tries to trigger their emotions. I acknowledge that any threat to the well-being of our children is overwhelmingly anxiety provoking. Here is where Gray Rock can be applied selectively to draw attention away from what really matters to you. In general, show no emotion to the offending behaviors or words. The psychopath will try different tactics to see which ones get a reaction. With Selective Gray Rock, you choose to respond to the tactic which matters least to you. This will focus the psychopath’s attention on that issue. Remember, the psychopath has no values, so he doesn’t understand what is valuable to us unless we show him. Selective Gray Rock shows him a decoy. When protecting our children, we can take a lesson from nature: Bird parents who have fledglings are known to feign a broken wing when a predator is in the vicinity. They fake a vulnerability to detract the cat’s attention from their real vulnerability, their babies. In this example, Selective Gray Rock fades all emotions into the background except the ones you want the predator to see.
Why it works:
A psychopath is easily bored. He or she needs constant stimulation to ward off boredom. It isn’t the type of boredom that normal people experience; it’s more like the French word, ennui, which refers to an oppressive boredom or listlessness. Drama is a psychopath’s remedy for boredom. For drama, they need an audience and some players. Once the drama begins, they feel complete and alive again. They are empowered when pulling the strings that elicit our emotions. Any kind of emotions will do, as long as it is a response to their actions.
A psychopath is an addict. He is addicted to power. His power is acquired by gaining access to our emotions. He is keenly aware of this and needs to constantly test to make sure we are still under his control. He needs to know that we are still eager to do his bidding, make him happy and avoid his wrath. He needs to create drama so he can experience the power of manipulating our emotions. As with any addiction, it is exhilarating to the psychopath when he gets his supply of emotional responses. The more times he experiences a reward for his dramatic behavior, the more addicted he becomes. Conversely, when the reward stops coming, he becomes agitated. He experiences oppressive boredom and he will counter it by creating more drama. If we stay the course and show no emotions, the psychopath will eventually decide that his toy is broken. It doesn’t squirt emotions when he squeezes it anymore! Most likely, he will slither away to find a new toy.
The Gray Rock technique does come with a caveat: psychopaths are dangerous people, if you are in a relationship with one that has already decided to kill you, it will be difficult to change his mind. He may already be poisoning you or sabotaging your vehicle. Take all necessary precautions. In this case, Gray Rock can only hope to buy time until you can make your escape.
How it works:
Psychopaths are attracted to shiny, pretty things that move fast and to bright lights. These things, signal excitement and relieve the psychopath’s ever-present ennui. Your emotional responses are his food of choice, but they aren’t the only things he wants.
He envies everything pretty, shiny and sparkly that you have and he wants whatever you value. You must hide anything that he will notice and envy. If you happen to be very good looking, you need to change that during this time. Use makeup to add bags under your eyes. If you aren’t married to the psychopath, any money or assets he covets should disappear “in a bad investment decision” (consult with your attorney on this). Your shiny sports car has to go, get a beater. If you have a sparkling reputation, anticipate that he will or has already begun to slander you; therefore, don’t allow yourself to be put into any compromising position or pushed into erratic behavior. The reason he wants to take these things from you, is not necessarily because he wants them for himself, it’s because he wants to see the emotions on your face when you lose them. He wants the power trip associated with being the one who took them from you. By preemptively removing these things from his vision and not reacting with emotion at the losses, you continue to train him with the idea that you are the most boring person on earth, someone he would never want to be.
Origin of Gray Rock:
In 2009, I left my psychopathic partner after 25 years, but I didn’t understand what was wrong with him. I sat in a sushi bar, lost in confusion, when a tall, athletic man introduced himself. To my own surprise, I instinctively poured out my story to him. This complete stranger listened to my story and then he explained to me that I was dealing with a malignant narcissist. He advised me, “Be boring.” He told me that his girlfriend would come home each night, begin drinking and become abusive. They were both professionals who traveled in the same professional circles. He knew that she would stalk him if he broke up with her and he didn’t want to risk the slander and drama which could leak out and damage his professional reputation.
His solution was to be so boring that she would simply leave him. He declined to go out on evenings and weekends. He showed no emotional reaction about anything, no interest in anything and responded with no drama. When she asked if he wanted to go out for dinner, his reply was, “I don’t know.” After a few months of no drama, she simply moved out.
Why is it called Gray Rock?
I chose the words Gray Rock because I needed an object for us to channel when we are in an emotionally charged situation. You don’t just practice Gray Rock, you BECOME a Gray Rock. There are gray rocks and pebbles everywhere you go, but you never notice them. None of them attract your attention. You don’t remember any specific rock you saw today because they blend with the scenery. That is the type of boring that you want to channel when you are dealing with a psychopath. Your boring persona will camouflage you and the psychopath won’t even notice you were there. The stranger in the sushi bar showed great insight when he advised me to “be boring.” He struck at the heart of the psychopath’s motivation: to avoid boredom.
In nature, there are many plants and creatures that show us how to survive in a world of predators. Among others, birds feign injury to protect their babies and mice play dead until the cat loses interest. Both of these tactics can be useful and they can be channeled when applicable. Yet, it’s difficult to calculate each and every move that a psychopath will make and to determine the best course of action each time. Instead of trying to out-think him, channel the gray rock. This simple, humble object in nature has all the wisdom it needs to avoid being noticed, it’s boring.
Copyright © 2012 Skylar
I don’t know….I’ve found that usually when I ignore someone, they just go away. Not everyone has innate fears of rejection – some do. I don’t think sociopaths have those fears. They are more motivated by desire to win. If you ignore a sociopath, then they will think they lost and try harder to win. Or they will lose interest in the game if you are not playing and go find someone else to play with. That is my understanding of their motivations. But who knows? Maybe there are some hybrid type spaths who have some fears of loss of love.
I totally agree about your description of the borderline personality, Michael. Sadly, I have these tendencies myself, so I know them all to well.
It is my opinion that true spaths are cold calloused and unfeeling. If one agrees that spaths don’t have feelings, then being gray rocked won’t affect them b/c they simply don’t care. Spaths number one motivation is domination/control. Therefore, gray rock does not deter them. NOTHING stops an spath bent on whatever their goal is.
Gray rock works for someone with feelings, like a narcissist. If someone is borderline, it may actually incite them.
Katy, sounds like you and Sky differ on this point. She says that if you grey rock a spath, they will just lose interest and move to greener pastures. I think it probably depends on the spath and what their particular game is. When I went NC with that spath in 2008, he stalked me one time. When my friend humiliated him during the stalking incident, and when I exposed him to the army, he left me alone. Never had the opportunity to practice grey rock. I have never hung out with a spath long enough or had my life entwined enough with one to need to employ it.
Katy, in some situations where contact is UNAVOIDABLE such as in co-parenting with a psychopath, or in my case with business with my son C or my egg donor, GRAY ROCK is the only way I can interact with them…it is giving them no “emotion” and just like Sargent Joe Friday (for you young folks google that name and rank) “JUST THE FACTS, MAM” with NO emotion. It keeps the drama from forming in these situations.
Not reacting to their drama, it is more than “shunning” I think.
In fact, I think NC is more “shunning” than gray rock is. Total refusal to interact with someone is showing them that you do not want anything to do with them, that they are not important to you, and that no matter how much they throw a pity party, or rage you are not going to participate. I think it ENRAGES many psychopaths and they DO increase their efforts to get you to break NC. Many times they are successful and reel us back in with their threats, or if that doesn’t work, the pity ploy, and so on, they spin around trying to find SOME manipulation that will work. If one doesn’t work, they will try another. Threats don’t work? Go to love bomb? That doesn’t work, then threaten! Not see the discord in flipping from one to the other? That’s a psychopath for you.
Star,
I define spath differently. I define spath with the same adjectives I defined my x!husband, as someone void of empathy, as cold/calloused as in “capable of viewing some they profess to love in great pain with detached observation and then walk over them to go hang out with the person who beat them until they were nearly dead.” My x!husband would kill cows to watch how they died.
Grey rock would be something a true spath would not even notice, what others do to them has NO emotional impact on them b/c they do not respond to emotions. Their motivation is to do that which they defined as “WINNING”.
Oxy
My perspective was that grey rock was sim to behaviors that Amish(?) Quakers (?)use. I have seen it in other churches, where the church members decide to not engage with a member in order to drive them away.
I am not saying that there are times when we can not avoid an spath. Of course there are. I was trying to draw a distinction between the two behaviors, whereas One is towards the spath (grey rock) where you don’t avoid the person, they are merely ignored…. and the other is for self protection (NC). Either way there are always exceptions.
And as you say, neither works with an spath that you have to maintain contact. NC worked for my spath b/c I went off grid and his only contact was via my attorney. I moved thousands of miles away to a city he would Never have guessed me to move to. I did not contact him. By not allowing his drama in my world, I found the space to recover.
In my humble opinion gray rocks works for several reasons
if we engage in the drama, respond to them, we’re allocating more energy, and time to the spath. We should limit it as much as we can.
also, if we respond to the drama, we’re enabling the spath to have influence over his environment. we’re the rattle, he’s the baby, and he wants to hear sound and see activity. If he doesn’t get any, he’ll get bored.
Those two reasons alone are pretty good reason in my view to go gray rock
I have to agree with Katy that with the violent “win or die” type psychopath like her X apparently was and my son Patrick is, gray rock wouldn’t have any effect on them, they would just consider it a WIN because you were beaten down to a nothing, left without emotion.
I know for a fact that Patrick has to WIN or die trying or kill you as a way to “win”—-I saw some tells back when but didn’t realize until in retrospect what they were.
Back when I was talking with him about how I planned to divy up my X husband’s personal possessions in a sort of lottery by piling them into X number of piles then numbering the piles and having the kids pick a number from 1 to X…so it would be ENTIRELY FAIR….he screamed at me in a letter….NO!!! Don’t do this til I get home, you’re his wife, you DON’T HAVE TO BE FAIR.” What he was saying actually, the “tell” as it were was that HE WANTED IT ALL. That to him was the way it SHOULD be.
I love my step kids and they love me I think, and I want them to have these personal items of their dad—I’ve got tons of magazine articles about him, and news clippings from decades ago. He was a really outstanding man in his field. So I scanned all the documents and then divided up the originals to the kids so each one can have something that is old, but have ALL the copies.
I see now what Patrick’s idea was that he would get everything, even if it meant killing David and me and Son C and even egg donor if she didn’t die soon enough to suit him. He didn’t like the idea that he couldn’t sell the farm or every own it out right because of the trust, only a life estate, but that was better than having to split it up with other heirs or work for a living. Plus with a nice base here he could be a big shot with his schemes….he thought or thinks. He sure didn’t want me to live longer than the egg donor though because then he would have gotten NOTHING….and that didn’t suit him at all. Having me fight his parole wasn’t in his plan either, but hopefully I can keep him there another few years anyway. Will just have to see what happens. I sure don’t want a gun fight at the OK corral, but if it comes it comes and I’m ready for it.
Oxy, isn’t that the point of gray rock? The spath feels they have won, so they go away and look for someone else to play with?
Star, I think it depends on the situation….if a wife say whose P husband beats her tries gray rock to try to get him to leave her by not crying when he beats her, by not showing any emotion, he is going to feel he “won” but he will keep on beating her because he LIKES TO DO THAT…in fact, he may beat her worse to make her cry.
My egg donor when she would whip me when I was a kid would usually stop as soon as I started to cry. When I got to be a rebellious teenager and decided one day she WOULD NOT MAKE ME CRY, she beat me with the buckle end of a belt til the blood ran down my back and my step father had to pull her off of me. My “gray rock” no emotion, no crying only infuriated her more because she wanted me to cry. That was her “win” so she would do what she had to do to get it.
So in SOME situations like with a co-parenting thing, keeping the emotions in check in dealing with them is a FABULOUS idea, gray rock all the way. It may help keep him from enjoying the interactions and pushing your buttons, or at least see the results of pushing them.
In other situations you have to GET OUT NOW all the gray rock in the world won’t keep you alive or make them go away.
IT IS ONLY *ONE* TOOL in a tool belt of dealing with psychopaths, it is NOT the ONLY TOOL in my opinion.