Every other week I participate in a ‘one word’ blog carnival. This week’s word was ‘grief’.
Grief. A tiny word. Five letters. ‘i’ before ‘e’. A story of precedence. What comes before grief? Love. Friendship. Familiarity. Hope. A belief in tomorrow. A belief in another day. A better day. A different time. A time for endless hello’s to fill our day with promise. A time to love.
And then death sweeps in and robs us of that time. That moment. Those endless hellos punctuated by good-byes that do not mean, never more, but rather, until later, until we meet again, until the next time.
In death’s embrace we fall and grieve for the one who was lost, for what was lost, for time lost and never to be recaptured.
In grief there is no next time. No better time. No later. Grief consumes all time and steals all hope of a better tomorrow.
Grief.
When love ends, we grieve. We grieve the passing of what could have been, should have been, might have been, if only. We search for ways to give meaning to our pain, to explain the sometimes inexplicable causes leading to loves demise. Sometimes, we talk it out. We make arrangements on how to separate, how to divide loves spoils, how to survive loves loss. We draw up agreements, outline custody and visitation arrangements. We divvy up assets and liabilities, arrange for payment. We divorce and move on with our lives, sometimes poorer but always richer in experience.
When we have loved an abuser, love cannot die. Love never existed. There was no mutual agreement to love honestly, truthfully, respectfully. There was only the abuser’s mask hiding his or her intent to deceive. There was only the lie we did not know existed.
In love’s vanishing out the door slamming behind their last words, we hang our hopes on one more chance to say, ‘good-bye’. On one more time to see their face, hear their voice, be in the presence of the love we believed to be true.
In our grief we plead for one last time. We pray, he will return. We pray, he or she, the one we loved, will come back if only to give us a chance to secure the elusive closure our empty arms yearn for. We want to say good-bye on our terms. We want to have the last word, to make them hear us, see us, feel our pain, witness our anguish. We want to know they understand the harm their passing through our lives has caused. We want them to ‘see’ how much we love in the hopes that the one we loved, the one we believed to be true, will return. We want one more chance. One more time. One more good-bye.
And so we plead with time to give us this one last chance so that we can come to terms with their good-bye. So that we can steal the time to learn to grieve on our terms.
And that is the lie we tell time. Give us a chance and we will make them hear us, just this once, so we can grieve freely.
It never happens. It can’t. Because grieving an abuser is the greatest betrayal of all. In having loved a lie, we can never grieve what never was.
With our empty arms and broken dreams, we must give into grief and mourn for the one who was lost. The woman who was abused. The woman who was lost. The woman who fell. The woman who was betrayed and who betrayed herself. We must mourn for the one we must love the most. Ourselves.
Once upon a time I loved a man who was untrue. He never really existed, though I searched for him between the lines he spoke that were all lies. Between the pages of my journal where I wrote of love ever lasting and promises of happily-ever after. I searched for him in every nook and cranny of my mind, desperately trying to make real the unreal. To make sense of the nonsense that was his passing through my life. I searched and held onto the hope that the pain, the turmoil, the sorrow was all a lie and he would turn up and be true.
It never happened. It couldn’t. He was the lie.
And in my facing the truth of his deceit, I grieved. I grieved for the dream that could never be, the love that never was. I grieved for the woman who was abused. The woman who lost herself in the arms of an abuser. I grieved for the pain she endured, the pain she caused. I grieved and cried and wished and hoped and prayed upon every star that the pain would cease, the tears would dry up and my heart would be healed. I prayed for the past to be erased. The lies to be vanished. The horror to be undone.
Nothing can undo the past. There is nothing that can be changed in yesterday.
Grieving a love that never was is part of the illusion of loving an abuser. We look for meaning in our memories and come up empty.
On either side of grief is love.
Grieving for the woman who lost herself in the arms of an abuser, set me free to fall into the arms of love.
In grieving for all that was lost, all that was forgotten on the stormy waters of his lies, I embraced all that was possible when I set myself free to sail upon the sea of love that surrounds me, sustains me, and lifts me up.
Love has no limits. Love knows no bounds. Love is my answer.
Stand in love. Grow in love. Be love.
In mourning for the one who lost herself in the arms of a man who was untrue, I found myself. I found myself and fell in love with all that I can be when I set myself free to live this one wild and precious life free to be all I am when I let go of grief and fall… in love.
Dear Louise,
As always, your words flow, smoothly carrying me along like a canoe floating down stream on a placid creek. Thank you for your inspiring article. (((hugs)))
Today my S called again with the I don’t believe your letting this end like this. It took a ounce of energy out of me I’m at work and can barely hold my head up, I can barely pay attention to what’s going on around me, I don’t want to believe that this just him trying to gain power but in my gut I don’t trust him he’s done to many mean an hurtful things to me! I didn’t get a chance to ask him why did he do this, he told he left me because of he was dealing with financial problems, ok yeah right he’s living with another brode, I don’t know what this person want from me it nothing left to give him I’m broke as hell and my spirit is broken its nothing left of me to give.
Dear Luv,
Sweetie, as long as you listen to him, you are giving him control ove ryour emotions. When he calls, HANG UP, do not talk or listen, as soon as you hear his voice, hang up. That is taking back YOUOR CONTROL OF YOU! That is why NO CONTACT is so important, nothing they say is TRUE so why listen. He isn’t going to tell you WHY, or WHAT, he just wants to control you and CONTINUE to lie to you. It gives him pleasure to CONTROL YOUR EMOTIONS. Take back your control, HANG UP!
Always beautifully written and inspiring words Donna, thank you.
I have realized lately that I have yet to greive for the love I thought I had, the man I thought I was married to. Whenever I try to go there, it all falls apart in a mess of lies and deception, his and my own to myself. Perhaps I don’t need to. Perhaps just living my life with purpose and finding joy in the NOW is enough to leave all that deception and usurpation of my rights behind.
Perhaps I have greived mostly in my dreams. I have had frequesnt dreams where he is back – he is present- and being his sweet, attentive, caregiver, provider, I’ll take care of everything self. These dreams always wake me up in horror, saying NO NO NO soemwhere between the dream and awakening.
Last night I dreamt a funny dream. I laughed at him. He was absurd in his posturing, a clown taking himself VERY seriously. As he does in real life, you will never hear a self deprecating joke or remark from him.
Anyhow, in the dream, he was wearing a ridiculous outfit of ski jacket and pants – white with large baby blue “fleur de Lise” all over the ensemble. Well obviously my subconcious humor taking a swipe at his changes of allegiance, and his pretending to be flavor of the month, as the symbols in my dream are that of the Quebec flag,his province of origin.
In the real world he has now apparently wrapped himself in the “flag” of the Catholic church……aaagggghhhhhh…
So the greiving for the lost “lover” is a lot like greiving for the chameleon, when he looked like cake frosting, rather than pond scum.
Laughing at him in my dream tells me I have made it to the other side of grief, he is now just a weird paradox disquising evil intent.
Peace and love,
I have been having trouble lately.
I think it involves the loss of closure, but I am not sure.
Last night I went to be at 9pm knowing sleep is one of my friends in weathering the storm with my X S/P.
I could not sleep, really, because evrytime I fell asleep I dreamt of the OW. Seeing her caught in his web. picking out wedding cake and wedding gowns, throwing a weddng shower.
The whole time I am running around telling anyone, her, her relatives who lies behind the mask.
I am desperate, I am heart-broken, I am frustrated; worse than a mime or a small, not yet verbal child trying to communicate, because I AM speaking a language the understand, they just don’t believe me.
ANY DREAM INTERPRETERS HERE?
I know someone did once, but I don’t remember who.
I think this reflects my false belief that he will always be believed and I am always seen as the liar.
In court it has been my greatest fear, but although he never gets what he deserves, I am always beleived.
I just had to share…I think this is greiving.
Thank you, Louise. Oh, how this touches my heart–
I’m still at the stage of struggling with that notion that he didn’t love me. What appeared to be our love was so strong, I think because I invested so totally in it, so much so that I think he really felt something like love. He even called me “my love.” I honestly believe he did love me as much as he was capable of loving, and so he was absolutely stunned when I left him. Yes, I left him, or have been trying to leave him for three months, but this ambivalence over this love thing has caused me to talk to him still, a bit. But I won’t let myself see him.
I too had dreams — for a month before I did the big break, I would wake up with a horrible screaming fear in my gut. Our break up started when some of his neighbors gave me a private message that had forced my rosy lenses to fall from my eyes, and suddenly I had begun to see all the manipulations behind so much of what he did, and I saw the clues he’d been dropping all along, and began to take the threats really quite seriously. And I felt cornered. What he wanted from me, I think, is status, but somewhere in our relationship he MAY have discovered a woman with more of a mind than he had counted on (I have more than one degree and work a pretty high powered job), and I sense he took some delight (if that’s possible) in the fact I am, for the most part, terrifically rational, and an easy person to talk to. Even he made the comment that talking to me is more like talking to a man.
After I left him, I had a dream in which he and my mother had me between them, and they were playing tug o’ war with my body. I’ve also had dreams where he breaks into my apartment with a mask on his face, and others where, like Anitasee, he is that sweet, funny, and terrifically sexy man I fell for. I’m usually pretty good at dream imagery; I don’t think these dreams are terrifically symbolic – they’re merely the memories and desires that are lingering in your mind. Anitasee’s flag dream is much more healthy, because, yes, you’re finding ways to refigure him so he’s not so appealing.
But yes, I still struggle too when he calls, because we did have many many of those good times. It’s just the scary times, or the times when he was screaming at me, or flirting with other women, that keep me from rushing back.
but I still miss him so! Or I miss the “us” I created in my mind when I was with him, and he was stable. That’s the hardest part of all.
Dear Banana,
I think sometimes our dreams are symbols, but I think also that they are not “spooky” but they may be trying to TELL US something as our mind tries to work these things out inside our subconscious.
I used to dream that there were baby animals or helpless old people I had to find and held out, and all the while a horse drawn wagon pulled either by my donkeys or my dead horse, would be left unattended and wander off and wreck while I was taking care of the baby ainmals in distress or the old people in need.
One night I dreamed of my egg donor who was giving me hell in the dream and my wonderful step father came there in the dream (he is deceased) and I was trying to get him to make her see reason and I realized he believed me and even years ago I should have turned to him for help with her and I didn’t.
I think the wagon represented my life and my unattended needs, and that I kept giving to others while neglecting my own life—always feeling that if I didn’t take care of others they would “die” and it was my responsibility to keep them alive and tend to them, even though my own needs were not met.
Once I “figured that out” then I stiopped having those dreams. I still have dreams that I remember from time to time, and like all dreams they are DREAMS and don’t make a lot of sense, but there is no PATTERN to them any more, and they are not about my P son or my egg donor etc. Just dreams.
If I had to “interpret” your dream I think you have already done it, you think people will disbelieve you, and you think she will have this “lovely life” with him (for a while) but you are wanting to warn her and can’t, so you are frustrated. Those are all natural emotions for you to have, but I think recognizing them, acknowledging them, etc even in your dreams is actually a step forward in that your psyche is working things out while you sleep.
You are making progress, Banana, I know that, and it won’t all happen in one day, but you are doing I think so much better now than you were when you first came here. He isn’t going to change, but you CAN and I think ARE changing your reactions toward what he does, and are not so panic stricken. Good going, sweetie! (*(hugs))))
Louise,
This article is so beautiful (as your writing always is.) I am still in the greiving process. And your words are so inspiring and true. Thank you for sharing. These words especially made me well up with tears…..
“When we have loved an abuser, love cannot die. Love never existed. There was no mutual agreement to love honestly, truthfully, respectfully. There was only the abuser’s mask hiding his or her intent to deceive. There was only the lie we did not know existed.”
“It never happens. It can’t. Because grieving an abuser is the greatest betrayal of all. In having loved a lie, we can never grieve what never was. ”
I was discussing this with my therapist this past Wednesday. How unfair it is that I’m greiving a love that never was. The realization that the unbound, unconditional love that I shared so freely was in vain. The betrayal and emptiness it makes me feel is overwhelming. Love never existed because I never saw the real him. To know that 4 years of my life were a lie, and that I invested my heart, time and energy into the illusion he wanted me to believe is devastating. So why then, do I greive so hard for something that never was? She tells me it’s because I have such a big heart and because I’m not a robot and I FEEL. But I don’t want to feel pain and sorrow for him any more. His lies don’t derserve my tears. I know it’s part of the process, but no matter how good my days are, filled with positive friends, family and school, his betrayal is never far from my thoughts. My pain is right under the surface still. There will never be the explanations that I believe I deserve, there will never be the apology that he owes, he will never experience the sorrow for what he did to me. So I learn to just except. It is what it is. These are things that I cannot control. Never did. But I can control my future and my happiness. He never deserved my love and therefore he doesn’t deserve my greif anymore. Thank you for your articles, they always help.
And banana, I think dreaming is part of the healing process as well. I dream of him often and just a few nights ago, I had a dream that was so realistic, I woke up in a panic and so angry. I dreamt that I went over to see him and when he greeted me, it was so cold and awkward, and he refused to kiss me, but tried to do it in a nonchalant manner. He gave me the cheek instead and I pulled back puzzled. I looked in his eye, and he couldn’t look at me, so I went to kiss him again and he pulled away. He seemed nervous and detached. I asked what his problem was and why he wouldn’t kiss me? He didn’t have an answer. And in my dream I remember having a moment of clarity that I knew immediately that he was cheating, and then I woke up. But it’s poetic in a way, because I believe it was my dream reminding me that I should move on. That he was a monster and was cold and decieving and that I needed to realize that so I can greive and let go. Dreams can be very powerful and I believe that they all mean something. They are just a bridge from the unconscious to the conscious. I wish I could sit down with someone to interpret all of my dreams about him too. Hope you find the answers that your dreams hold. Hugs.
amber,
You said :
There will never be the explanations that I believe I deserve, there will never be the apology that he owes, he will never experience the sorrow for what he did to me.
These things are some of the same things a suicide survivor feels when they loose their significant other. These unanswered questions/issues really do COMPLICATE the griveing journey. And it is important not to get stuck there. (I was told)
The biggest question that a suicide survivor faces is WHY? And I think that is much the same question a survivor of a relationship with an S/P/N also ask themselves. How could this happen? In the very begining (of acceptance) the whole thing also seems very surreal.
In my own recovery before I could actually move into the actual grieving-healing part of the journey…I HAD to answer some of my own questions/issues. I knew I wouldn’t get the answer elsewhere (and with an S/P/N you wouldn’t get a TRUTHFUL answer even if they did provide you an answer anyways.)
I think it is also important to search your soul for the most important questions or issues that you have, and not get lost in the process of coming up with more questions that you could possibly have answers to.
In my case there were 3 that I had to come up with my own answers to. Maybe your counselor could help you with this.
My therapist at the time helped me explore this but I in the end, had to come up to my own conclusions.
However one of the questions I had the MOST difficulty with he provided me with an answer that I could live with.
At the time I carried the “guilt” of how could I have known someone so intimately and not see this coming? No signs. No red flags. Nothing, even in hindsight. I considered myself to be a pretty intuitive person and HAD seen all the red flags (dry drunk) that my husband was going to drink again. So how could I NOT see this coming. (they both happened simultaneously, the relapse and the suicide)
He asked me if my husband had ever relapsed before in earlier attempts in his recovery…..And I said, sure lots of times….And then he said, did he ever attempt suicide before? And I said. No, never.
It wasn’t something that I could have possibly known. There were no clues. He didn’t leave any.
Give yourself the TRUTHFUL “explanation” that you deserve to continue your journey. You know enough already, to know you wouldn’t get the truth from him anyways. Although you know you can’t get a sincere apology from him, I am sure your counselor can give you some advice on how to give yourself something more worthwile than an insincere apology from him. And finally unfortunately he isn’t capable of feeling any sorrow for what he did to you. But you can embrace yourself here, and KNOW that you DESERVE so much better than what you got…
I think you are growing in leaps and bounds 🙂
Louise, I did all that, except before I moved to LOVE and freedom, I first yearned again for one last meeting, one last chance to see him, but this time to laugh in his face, to tell him that he only caught me in a down time, that he isn’t that skilled, that he drips with red flags, that I know his games now, his lies, his predatory nature. I wanted to see him one last time to laugh, and tell him he is not even worthy of my anger. Then I had to grieve again, to realize that even those dreams of closure are based on the lie that somehow what I said or did would impact him. Of course, nothing from me would ever impact him. You begin to comprehend how very, very empty it all was….